poster

Patriot Box Office Media Player Review

Usability Issues

While the navigation is very funtional, it is not very user friendly at all, and is the only part that makes you feel like you’re using a computer rather than a video appliance.  One of the biggest usability issues of a video device is the aforementioned Spousal Acceptance Factor (SAF).  Although my wife is more technically-savvy than most, she had a hard time understanding how to use the appliance at first.

The remote control is also functional, but there are a lot of things that could use some improvement.  There are hard physical buttons, so you can “feel” your way across the remote, but the options you will use most often (Go To, back, skip, and fast forward) are on completely different parts of the remote, which can be hard to find.  The remote does not offer any illuminated options, which make it even more difficult to use in a dimly-lit room.

While playing a movie, there is no time indicator to show how far in you are.  The only option is a somewhat hidden box accessed by the “Playback Search” box, which allows you to enter the Title number, Chapter number, or Time.  Any type of video other than a DVD or Bluray image will skip using the Time indicator.  You must press the “Playback Search” button, then press down two times, then right to highlight the time. and then press up and down to change the time increments and then press Enter.  This is way too demanding when I just want to skip the intro credits.  If I’ve already seen part of a movie, I don’t want to have to guess how many minutes I’ve already watched, or press the Skip button 20 times.  I really wish there was a bar, thumbnails, or other navigation method that was a lot easier to use.  A system primarially intended to watch AVI files such as this should have a much more user-friendly way to watch the movies.

There are also no video scaling options, other than zooming in.  Once you have set the aspect of your display, you are at the mercy of the video file’s aspect ratio.  The only way I could fill a 4:3 TV show to full screen was to use the internal scaling options of my TV, and your mileage will vary depending on your TV.

One feature we did like was that the Box Office automatically plays the next video file in the folder when finished, rather than going back to the navigation menu.  This can be both a blessing and a curse, however.  We like to have a queue of shows running when we fall to sleep, but they could still be playing when we wake up.  You’ll have to rely on the “sleep timer” function on your TV if you want it to shut off.

Audio
Switching audio tracks is relatively easy.  Just press the “audio” button on the remote and you’ll be presented with the language tracks.  Keep pressing the button to toggle through the available audio options.  There aren’t a lot of AVIs that have multiple audio tracks, but many MKV files usually have lots of them.  It’s also great to encode a Rifftrax audio track with a movie, so you can enjoy both versions of the movie without the bulk of two seperate files.

Compatibility
We tested the Box Office on a very wide variety of media formats.  AVI files (especially older ones) can have a lot of different audio and video codecs, and for the most part the Box Office played them all.  There were a few issues that we couldn’t resolve.  The MPEG-2 files from a Sony Camcorder would play, but the audio would drop on subsequent files.  If we manually stopped and restarted, then the audio was fine.  Short MPEG-4 files created with the Pinnacle Video Capture Device (reviewed here) would actually cause the device to crash, which required a hard power cycle.  Overall, the device played just about every file we could throw at it, and its compatibility is way more robust than any other UPNP streaming device, including the Playstation 3.

7 Comments

  1. Pingback: HTPC vs Consoles, Boxee, XBMC, WMC?—OCmodshop.com

  2. Kyle

    December 14, 2011 at 1:04 pm

    From an external USB DVD Drive, you can play any file you can play on the device itself, just as if it was removable storage, but you can play DVDs, with DVD file structure, as long as it does not have the anti-piracy stuff on them, they will play DVDs that were copied using DVDFab and such.

  3. Alan

    June 20, 2011 at 1:14 am

    @Rae: I'm not sure if you can play media from an existing PBO, but given the existing peer options you should be able to do it. If not, then use a USB hard drive or use a central PC or NAS as a media server.

  4. Alan

    June 20, 2011 at 1:14 am

  5. Rae

    June 20, 2011 at 1:14 am

    Do you know if you can create or access playlists on one PBO via either UPNP or NET from a second PBO that has the USB HD attached to it? Obviously, I don't want to have to have two hard drives with media
    content doubled on both machines. But I'd like to be able to set it up so that several video files will play back to back and repeat. Thanks!

  6. Alan

    June 20, 2011 at 1:14 am

    That's right… a physical DVD movie will not play like it does in a DVD player. If you have an .ISO image it will. If you put in a DVD with Divx files on it, they will play just fine.

  7. dlb

    June 20, 2011 at 1:13 am

    According to the review, standard DVDs will NOT play via a USB DVD drive, only ISOs. Does this mean that the DVD has to have the actual ISO file, or it has be the image contained within the ISO? What if a a data DVD has several DivX AVI files on it? What about VCDs? Will this unit play VCDs via a USB DVD drive?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>